On January 14, 2022, the evaluation meeting of the Whole Process Design of the Campus Construction Project of Georgia Tech Shenzhen Institute Tianjin University (project number: 2018-440300-83-01-706769004) was held at the conference room of JW Marriott Shenzhen via on-site meeting + teleconferencing. The bid evaluation results have been announced on the website of Shenzhen Construction Project Trading Service Network.From Shenzhen Construction Project Trading Service NetworkThe Result of Bid Evaluation本项目评审办法采用记名投票法（逐轮淘汰），因暗标号1号方案投标文件违反招标文件否决性条款相关规定，按废标处理。The project is evaluated by open ballot (elimination by rounds). The bidding documents of Sealed Bid 1 violated the provisions of veto clauses, and was deemed as an invalid bid according to the tender documents. 评审委员会对剩余6家单位提交的设计成果文件进行了详细的评审和深入的讨论，提出了各自的意见和建议。The jury committee conducted a detailed review and discussed thoroughly about the design deliverables submitted by the remaining six bidders. Opinions and suggestions were exchanged at the meeting. 经过 2 轮投票，最终评审委员会一致推荐以下3家单位为无排序的中标候选人：After two rounds of voting, the jury panel unanimously recommended the following 3 as the unranked winning candidates:
The Bid Evaluation Committee评审委员会由7名专家组成（排序不分先后）：梅洪元、金东寒、朱雄毅、徐昀超、吴林寿、于天赤、杨晓春，评审委员会推选 梅洪元 为评审组长。The jury committee consists of seven experts (listed in no particular order): Hongyuan MEI, Donghan JIN, Xiongyi ZHU, Yunchao XU, Linshou WU, Tianchi YU and Xiaochun YANG, wherein Hongyuan MEI was elected as the jury chair.中国工程院院士、哈尔滨工业大学建筑设计研究院院长、总建筑师
|中国建筑设计研究院有限公司 + CPG CONSULTANTS PTE LTDChina Architecture Design ＆ Research Group + CPG CONSULTANTS PTE LTD|
|艾奕康设计与咨询（深圳）有限公司 + 深圳市华汇设计有限公司AECOM + Shenzhen Huahui Design Co., Ltd|
|深圳市欧博工程设计顾问有限公司 + 海茵建筑设计咨询（北京）有限公司Shenzhen AUBE Architectural Engineering Design Co.,LTD(CHINA) + Henn Building Design Consulting (Beijing) Co.,Ltd|
Academician of Chinese Academy of Engineering, President of Architectural Design and Research Institute of Harbin Institute of Technology, Chief Architect
Academician of Chinese Academy of Engineering, President of Tianjin UniversityCCDI悉地国际集团副总建筑师、东西影工作室主持建筑师Deputy Chief Architect of CCDI Group, presiding architect of Dongxiying StudioPresiding architect of Xu Yunchao Architecture Studio of Shenzhen Architectural Design & Research InstitutePresiding Architect of WAU Architects建学建筑与工程设计所有限公司董事、总建筑师、深圳分公司总经理Director and Chief Architect of Jianxue Architecture and Engineering Design Institute Co., LTD, General Manager of Shenzhen BranchVice President of School of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shenzhen University, Director of the Urban Planning Department
评委合影（屏幕左：梅洪元 右：金东寒、前排左至右：吴林寿、徐昀超、于天赤、杨晓春、朱雄毅）Photo of judges（From left to right on the screen: Hongyuan Mei, Donghan Jin、From left to right in the picture: Linshou Wu, Yunchao Xu, Tianchi Yu, Xiaochun Yang, Xiongyi Zhu）Bid-winning Candidates (No Ranking)中国建筑设计研究院有限公司 + CPG CONSULTANTS PTE LTDChina Architecture Design & Research Group + CPG CONSULTANTS PTE LTD © China Architecture Design & Research Group + CPG CONSULTANTS PTE LTD
© China Architecture Design & Research Group + CPG CONSULTANTS PTE LTDComprehensive Comments of the Bid Evaluation Committee Highlights of the scheme:1.设计提出“都市深呼吸”的理念，整体布局有特色，疏密适宜，校园深度融合周边的山水与城市环境；1. The design puts forward the concept of "deep breathing in the city". With the unique and orchestrated layout, the campus is deeply integrated with the surrounding landscape and urban environment;2.南北集约、中间疏朗，形成了以学生为中心的中央生态绿谷，校园空间富有特色，有效响应天津大学佐治亚理工深圳学院的核心建设理念；2. Intensive north-south and sparse middle have formed a central ecological green valley with students as the center. The campus space is distinctive, which effectively responds to the core construction concept of Georgia Tech Shenzhen Institute Tianjin University;3. The scheme creates a new campus building image based on the green and low-carbon concept.Optimization suggestions:1.北侧单体中段教学和产学研中心部分密度偏大，宜进行优化；1. The building density is quite large concerning the teaching and production-learning-research center located on the mid-section of the northern building, which should be optimized.2.中央生态绿谷尽可能给师生提供更多的运动及活动空间。2. The Central Ecological Green Valley shall provide more entertainment and activity space for teachers and students to the greatest extent.艾奕康设计与咨询（深圳）有限公司 + 深圳市华汇设计有限公司AECOM + Shenzhen Huahui Design Co., Ltd ©AECOM + Shenzhen Huahui Design Co., Ltd ©AECOM + Shenzhen Huahui Design Co., Ltd
Comprehensive Comments of the Bid Evaluation Committee Highlights of the scheme:1.北侧集约式的布局与城市契合度较好，充分尊重山水自然环境，形成完整的城市界面；1. The intensive layout in the north side fits the city well, fully respecting the natural environment of the surrounding mountains and rivers, forming a complete urban interface;2. The site and landscape are expressed moderately, with distinct single building image;3.具有突出的教育建筑类型特征，为全生命周期的校园建设留有弹性。3. It has prominent characteristics of educational architecture, leaving possibilities for future development to complete the whole construction cycle.Optimization suggestions:1.北侧教研综合体、宿舍单体尺度结合南方气候特征与周边自然环境进行优化；1. The single scale of the north teaching and research complex and dormitory shall be optimized in combination with the climate characteristics in southern China and the surrounding natural environment;2. Lingnan style and localization can be further enhanced;3. The connection between the dormitory area and the west campus can be strengthened. 深圳市欧博工程设计顾问有限公司 + 海茵建筑设计咨询（北京）有限公司Shenzhen AUBE Architectual Engineering Design Co.,LTD(CHINA) + Henn Building Design Consulting (Beijing)Co.,Ltd ©Shenzhen Aube Conception + HENN Architecture©Shenzhen Aube Conception + HENN ArchitectureComprehensive Comments of the Bid Evaluation Committee Highlights of the scheme:1.五位一体、三区串联，模块化设计可满足校园对未来空间的可变及通用性需求；1. Integration of the five building blocks, connection of three areas and modular design can meet the variable and universal requirements of the future space of the campus;2.校园设计平和朴实，符合校园建筑安全、宁静的特质。2. The design of the campus is clean and simple, consistent with the safety and tranquility of the campus architecture.Optimization suggestions:1. The identification of key buildings can be strengthened;2.图书馆和体育馆分设在东、西两个生活区，结合功能需求进行优化。2. The library and gymnasium are set in the east and west of living areas respectively, which shall be optimized according to the functional requirements.
Reform Measures for Tendering
资格预审阶段，采用概念提案（暗标）评审、资信复核的评价模式，遴选出提案及团队实力“双优”一体的投标团队。In the pre-qualification stage, the bidding team integrating proposal and team strength is selected through the evaluation modes of concept proposal (sealed bid) review and credit review.方案评标阶段，将方案可实施性论证作为投标文件组成及评审要素，前置投标方案可实施论证，提高了各投标方案质量。In the bidding evaluation stage, the feasibility demonstration of the scheme is taken as the component and evaluation element of the bids, and the feasibility demonstration of pre-bidding schemes improves the quality of each bidding scheme.
6 评标工作点评评审结束后，与会专家对本次评标组织工作进行点评如下：After the review, the participating experts made comments on the organization of the whole bid evaluation process, which can be summed up as follows:将可实施性论证作为投标文件组成及评审要素之一，使得各投标方案回归理性，建议推广。The feasibility demonstration is regarded as one of the components and evaluation elements of the bids, so that the bidding schemes can return to rationality.本次评标工作组织严密、专业高效，专家在评审过程中感受到了工务署的公平公正、流程规范，认为不仅提高了业界投标水平，同时树立了“工务署招标”品牌，并表示乐意参加方案评标，愿意参加工务署组织的设计招标！The bid evaluation process was well organized with fairness and standardization, and was highly recognized by the juries. They believe that the evaluation not only reforms the bidding industry, but also establishes the brand of “Tender Organization by Bureau of Public Works of Shenzhen Municipality". They also expressed their willingness to participate in the future evaluation projects and design tenders organized by the Bureau of Public Works of Shenzhen Municipality.Engineering Design Management Center of Bureau of Public Works of Shenzhen MunicipalityGUANZHU Architectural Development Communication Center
Comments on Bid Evaluation